I’m making it a point to watch comfy, cozy Christmas movies this December, and last week I watched The Bells of St. Mary‘s (1945), which is considered a Christmas movie but isn’t only about Christmas. In fact, I think there are only a couple of Christmas-themed scenes in the movie.
(This post is part of the Comfy, Cozy Feature with Erin from Still Life, With Cracker Crumbs. Read more about it and join up to the linky here. )
I can’t believe it has taken me so long to watch this movie. I ended up loving it. The chemistry between the main stars, Bing Crosby and Ingrid Bergman, was outstanding. It was also nice to see Ingrid in a role with some humor because I’ve only ever seen her in more serious roles. And, of course, I love that Bing sang in this movie, even though it wasn’t a strict musical.
Bing Crosby arrives as the new priest at the St. Mary’s parish and is immediately told of how the former priest aged quickly because he had to help oversee a nun-run, school that is run-down and in the inner city.
The former priest also had to deal with Sister Superior Mary Benedict (Bergman), a woman with a strong personality who runs the school.
“I can see you don’t know what it means to be up to your neck in nuns,” the rectory housekeeper says.
Father O’Malley admits he doesn’t and the woman advises him to “sleep well tonight” as if implying it will be his last good night of sleep for a while.

Father O’Malley and Sister Benedict butt heads more than once but in passive-aggressive ways. One way they butt heads is in how to educate the children at the school. O’Malley is much softer in his approach while Sister Mary prefers levying harsher punishments.
She also doesn’t approve of fighting and instead suggests that boys turn the other cheek when they are bullied.
After witnessing a fight between two boys, Father O’Malley believes the young man who is at the receiving end of a punch should be able to fight back.
Sister Benedict disagrees and a good-natured duel between the two authority figures begins.

I enjoyed this exchange:
- Father Chuck O’Malley : Naturally, I like to see a lad who can take care of himself. On the outside, it’s a man’s world.
- Sister Mary Benedict : How are they doing, Father?
- Father Chuck O’Malley : Not doing too good, but, you know what I mean. There’s sometimes a man has to fight his way through.
- Sister Mary Benedict : Wouldn’t it be better to – to think your way through? That’s pure conjecture, of course, from someone on the – *inside*.
At the crux of the story is the need for a new school because the current one is falling down.
Sister Benedict is praying that the school’s new neighbor, Horace P. Bogardus, will be the one to provide it. Bogardus has built a huge, new, business building next to the school and Sister Benedict seems convinced that with enough prayer, Bogardus will turn the building over to the school.
There are many hilarious misunderstandings and interactions between the nuns, Father O’Malley, and Bogardus. Bogardus, by the way, is portrayed by Henry Travers, best known as the angel Clarence from It’s A Wonderful Life.
The storyline of a young girl – Patsy Gallagher – weaves into the movie and I found her storyline to be a bit of a distraction from the main story. The young girl’s mother sends her to St. Mary’s to avoid taking the same path as she did when she became a single mother and took on a dancing job to make ends meet.
I didn’t know this before I started researching the film but Bing first played Father O’Malley in a movie called Going My Way and actually won an Oscar for that role. I am not surprised because I actually thought that this performance was the best of his I’ve seen. Now I can’t wait to watch Going My Way, which I found “free” on Amazon with our Amazon Video subscription. Both movies were directed by Leo McCarey.
When The Bells of St. Mary’s First came out some critics said it was too much like Going My Way but without the charm of its predecessor.
A reviewer from Harrison Reports, however, disagreed and wrote: “As in Going My Way, which he also wrote, produced, and directed, Leo McCarey has proved again that great pictures do not require pretentious stories … The acting of the entire cast is excellent. Crosby delights one with his ease and natural charm, and Miss Bergman will undoubtedly rise to new heights of popularity because of the effective way in which she portrays her role.”
According to Wikipedia, the was nominated for Best Actor in a Leading Role (Bing Crosby), Best Actress in a Leading Role (Ingrid Bergman), Best Director, Best Film Editing, Best Music, Scoring of a Dramatic or Comedy Picture, Best Music, Song (for Jimmy Van Heusen (music) and Johnny Burke (lyrics) for “Aren’t You Glad You’re You”) and Best Picture.”
Bing’s nomination had him making history with him being the first actor in history to receive two nominations for portraying the same character in different films. “This was following the previous year’s nomination anomaly, where Barry Fitzgerald received nominations in both supporting and lead for the same film (as the same character), the prequel Going My Way. While he lost in lead to his co-star Crosby, Fitzgerald won for Best Supporting Actor.”

In the middle of the movie, there is an adorable rehearsal of the Christmas/nativity story with the cutest little kids – probably 5 to 7. It cracked me up and reminded me of a nativity program that my parents went to one time. According to my mom, a beautiful song was being sung as the little girl playing Mary reached down to the baby doll in her arms and twisted its head to face the right way in a very aggressive and unnatural move. Mom said the audience could barely hold in the laughter.
The Wikipedia article mentioned a couple other bits of trivia, which I thought were interesting:
“The Bells of St. Mary’s has come to be associated with the Christmas season, probably because of the inclusion of a scene involving a Christmas pageant at the school, a major plot point involving an unlikely (yet prayed for) gift, and the film’s having been released in December 1945. In the 1946 film, It’s a Wonderful Life, in which Henry Travers, a co-star of The Bells of St. Mary’s, plays the guardian angel Clarence Odbody, the title of The Bells of St. Mary’s appears on the marquee of a movie theater in Bedford Falls, New York. In The Godfather (1972), Michael and Kay see The Bells of St. Mary’s at Radio City Music Hall.”

The Bells of St. Mary was a very sweet film with a lot of humor, touching moments, and a beautiful Christmas message of love and taking care of others. As I mentioned above, I loved the interaction between Bing and Ingrid, but I also loved the carefree feeling of the acting between the young woman who portrayed Patsy and Bing.
I watched this film for free on Tubi but yesterday I also found it for free on YouTube here:






















